This article was originally published on Benefits PRO.
Benefits managers and their advisors should get company procurement teams involved with employer health benefits purchasing decisions, and they should start talking to procurement about the 2028 benefits year, or even the 2029 benefits year, now.
Benefits, HR, finance, and procurement all touch health plan decisions in some way, but few benefits leaders understand exactly where procurement fits or why it matters.
A typical private-sector employer’s benefits team manages plan design, coordinates with carriers and third-party administrators, handles enrollment and eligibility, communicates coverage changes to employees, and troubleshoots claims issues as they arise.
The employer’s human resources team handles talent strategy, workforce planning, compensation structure, and employee experience.
The chief financial officer’s team navigates the budget, forecasts cost trend,s and evaluates benefits spending against overall financial performance.
By contrast, the procurement team focuses on evaluating emerging supplier capabilities, leading sourcing events, negotiating contract terms and pricing, conducting supplier risk assessments, and applying category and market expertise to maximize the value of every dollar an organization spends.
Although brokers and advisors may provide some services that overlap with procurement, they typically don’t offer the same level of sourcing and negotiation expertise.
Their preferred supplier relationships may also limit an employer’s access to the broader marketplace and range of available options.
Spending on employer-sponsored health benefits is one of the largest but often one of the least-scrutinized categories in an organization’s budget.
Benefits rarely receive the same cross-functional rigor and procurement focus as other major spend categories.
That needs to change.
In 2026, premium increases ranged from 6% to 10%, with some employers seeing increases of more than 20%.
Medical and prescription costs have climbed roughly 52% since 2015.
Compared with 2026, organizations can expect annual health benefits costs to increase by approximately $1.2 million per 1,000 employees in 2027.
These cost trends won’t correct themselves.
Benefits planning must be employee-centered and benefits-led, but procurement-enabled.
Getting procurement involved earlier creates more time and structure to support employee benefits planning, drive savings, and evaluate alternatives.
That means benchmarking data to confirm pricing is competitive, disciplined request-for-proposal processes to surface new point-of-care and pharmacy benefit manager solutions, closer evaluation of plan design and broker fees, and vendor accountability for performance and cost commitments over the life of the contract.
The Renewal Calendar Doesn’t Leave Room for Delay
Many organizations run on a calendar-year plan, with decisions typically locked by August and open enrollment in October or November.
But starting the process in March or April simply doesn’t leave enough runway to remarket with carriers and seriously evaluate innovative point-of-care solutions or other emerging products and technologies.
The fix is really to kick off planning in December of the prior year, at the latest, with the chief human resources officer, the chief financial officer, and the chief procurement officer in the room from day one.
That way, all three functions can strategically weigh all the options and set the direction right from the start.
Even if you’re in the middle of the year or late in the year and carrier negotiations have concluded, there may still be opportunities to reduce or optimize total benefits spend.
Certain third-party solutions, such as select wellness programs and national diagnostic imaging services, can often be implemented outside the traditional benefits renewal cycle.
However, these mid-cycle opportunities should complement, not replace, proactive planning.
Organizations should begin developing their benefits strategy at least 13 months before the next plan year begins.
While The Clock Ticks, Costs Compound
For many CFOs, benefits tend to sit outside the categories they are actively negotiating and are treated more like a fixed cost than a managed one.
The CFO’s mandate is financial discipline and enterprise value; the CHRO’s mandate is talent strategy and workforce experience.
Those goals are interdependent, and procurement can be a connecting bridge between the two.
Every month of delay allows costs to rise and reduces the time available to evaluate alternatives.
Involving procurement early and proactively in the process embeds cost-saving expertise within a rigorous evaluation process, one with enough time to actually work.
A Real Evaluation Process Can’t Be Rushed
Dozens of new suppliers and point-of-care models are entering the market.
Some genuinely reduce costs; others just shift them around.
Some will negatively impact employees while others will improve the employee experience.
Sorting out which is which and building a repeatable process to keep evaluating going forward takes time and resources that most teams don’t have if they start in the second quarter.
That means the CHRO should come prepared to discuss three questions with their procurement partners:
- Where are our largest claim expense areas?
- What new solutions has our broker introduced recently, and how do they compare with leading solutions in the market?
- Where could procurement and finance add value alongside the broker relationship?
These questions will lay the groundwork for a more thoughtful and collaborative approach.
The right answers also depend on the industry.
A hospital system that is also its employees’ health plan provider has to weigh revenue impact alongside cost, not simply push people toward outside providers. A professional services firm evaluating benefits as core compensation will land in a different place than a retailer managing a largely hourly workforce.
None of that nuance surfaces without the runway to think it through.
About the Author
James Bouchard
Partner, Center of Excellence
